“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said in a rather scornful tone, “”it means just what I choose it to mean.”
Parliamentary drafters are a bit like Humpty Dumpty. And sometimes like Alice. They use words in legislation. Sometimes they rely on the ordinary and natural meaning. Sometimes they behave like Humpty Dumpty. When they behave like Humpty Dumpty, they can do some weird things.
“”In this Act “state’ includes “territory’,”” for example. Sometimes black is defined as white.
This makes legislation very hard to read. Especially big Acts, like the new Industrial Relations Act (about 400 pages). You do not know if Humpty Dumpty has been to work on a particular word, or what Humpty means by it, without constant thumbing back to the definition section.
Moreover, Humpty can sneak in definitions in other parts of the Act.
The new Industrial Relations Act which came in to force on March 30 is causing quite a deal of fear and loathing out there.
Continue reading “1994_04_april_ir”