The end of US altruism

Last week’s impeachment articles against US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth neatly highlight how much damage the Trump Administration has done to American “exceptionalism” and to US foreign policy generally. And there are lessons for Australia here.

Critically, Hegseth was accused of illegally waging and continuing military hostilities against Iran for more than 90 days in violation of the War Powers Resolution and without congressional authorisation.

The 240-year-old US Constitution gives the power to declare war exclusively to Congress. That was part of the post-revolutionary package that made the United States exceptional – different from Europe.

For centuries, European monarchs waged war against each other, dragging their people into loss of blood and treasure without their consent. The monarchs often made alliances to fight these wars, making them even bloodier.

The United States was to be different. It was to be governed, not ruled, and governed with the consent of those being governed. Only the people’s representatives in Congress could wage war. And treaties (usually the vehicle for alliances) had to be approved by two-thirds of the Senate.

After World War I, the war to end all wars, the US, under President Woodrow Wilson, embarked on a mission to do just that by creating the League of Nations that would outlaw all but defensive wars. Wilson was dismissed as an impractical idealist, the Senate rejected the League of Nations, and without the US at the forefront of world affairs, the League was unable to prevent World War II.

After World War II, the US was determined not to repeat the errors of the 1930s. The United Nations, which was shaped by President Franklin Roosevelt and Winston Churhill, became a key element of US foreign policy.

Critically, UN rules permitted armed conflict only in self-defence, or helping another nation’s self-defence, or with UN approval. The primary aim of US foreign policy was to support democracy and freedom against tyranny and autocracy. It would defend those attacked.

That was best expressed by President John Kennedy at his inauguration in 1961: “Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.”

Of course, the US often failed to live up to the ideal, but at least its heart was thought to be in the right place – helping others defend rather than acting offensively to grab and keep territory for itself. Contrast that with the Soviet Union after World War II. It was always out for territory, empire and influence, such as subjugating Hungary, Czechoslovakia and most of Eastern Europe and Central Asia.

The US attracted allies. The Soviet Union did not. The Warsaw Pact was kept together despite the wishes of its members’ people’s, not because of them.

The Vietnam War, however, proved that US determination to make liberty succeed was easily thrown off the rails. The US mischaracterised North Vietnamese nationalism as an extension of the Comintern – the world communist movement.

After that war the US, with Henry Kissinger leading foreign policy, adopted realpolitik. Forget altruism and the pursuit of liberty. National interest, pragmatism, and flexible alliances (even with authoritarian regimes) became the main game. But at least superficially and it name it was still underpinned by an ideal of pursuing democracy, human rights, and liberty.

Indeed, the banner of liberty and democracy was used to attract allies that would support the US in its pursuit of its national interests and realpolitik.

But in that pursuit the US still at least paid lip-service to the rules-based order. The US went out of its way to get UN approval for the Gulf wars and along with Britain, Australia and other allies dressed up the invasion of Iraq as a legal self-defensive action because of Iraq’s alleged possession of weapons of mass destruction.

There were no weapons of mass destruction. Nonetheless, the idea that the fact that a state might obtain weapons of mass destruction justified action against that state as an action in self-defence started to take hold. It was a legal fiction.

Trump and Hegseth have used it to justify unprovoked attacks and acts of war against Iran. Similarly, they have used the possibility of harm to US citizens caused by illegal drugs to justify lethal attacks on vessels suspected of carrying drugs and to justify the kidnapping of a foreign head of state.

These three kinds of unprovoked illegal acts of war under Trump’s administration have put an end to any pretence that the US is acting altruistically or on the side of the “goodies”, and made the US no better than any of its adversaries. It was putting America first, putting its national interest and pragmatism before the defence of democracy, human rights and liberty.

The Hegseth impeachment articles also cited the kidnapping of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro and the obliteration of the alleged drug runners (and any innocent passengers) without trial.

The flagrant lawlessness of Trump’s and Hegseth’s actions are an about-turn of the exercise of US foreign policy, from at least a stated aim of siding with democracy, liberty and human rights, into outright selfish pursuit of American interests and the political aims of those in power.

US allies and proponents of democracy and liberty generally wonder whether it can be reversed, and even if reversed, will the fact that Americans ever voted for Trump to be President remove the thought that it could easily happen again. The efficacy of any belief that the US will always be the standard-bearer for democracy, liberty, and decency in foreign affairs and the exercise of military power must surely now be in tatters if not dead.

The mid-terms could be seen as much as a repudiation of incumbency per se rather than a repudiation of the belligerent pursuit of American first and as an embrace of liberty, human rights and democracy.

It is sad that 250 years of America rising above the costly warmongering of divine-right kings in Europe is now over. But we must accept it rather than pretend that the mid-term elections mean that everything can go back to “normal” as if nothing has happened.

The lessons for Australia should be obvious. Australia’s entry into wars has been marked by Australian governments supplicating themselves to British and American decision-making. 

Prime Minister Andrew Fisher pledged Australia’s “last shilling” to Britain in entering World War I. In 1939 Prime Minister Robert Menzies announced Britain was at war therefore Australia was at war with Germany. Prime Minister Harold Holt went “all the way with LBJ” into the Vietnamese quagmire. Prime Minister Bob Hawke told Parliament we had committed to the First Gulf War days after the event. Prime Minister John Howard did the same with the Second Gulf War and on very shaky legal grounds.

People are rightly concerned that the AUKUS arrangement will sucker us in to a US-led war with China against our national interest and against legality and morality.

Australians should insist that we have national law binding governments that mandates that the nation does not enter military alliances or go to war without parliamentary debate and approval. Otherwise, we are little better than the belligerent, lawless, self-styled US Secretary for War. 

This article first appeared in The Canberra Times and other Australian media on 17 November 2026.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Password Reset
Please enter your e-mail address. You will receive a new password via e-mail.